Jump to content
  • windstruck Born-Kite Longstar: First Look Review


    Kite with potential, but in V-1.0 leaves quite a bit to get used to. 

    Positives
    High quality construction, very pleasing to the eye, strong pull for its size
    Negatives / Considerations
    Requires bar nursing to optimize flight. Odd behavior at edges of window. Tendency to fly backwards.

    I recently received a complete quiver of Born-Kite LongStars (3, 5, and 7m) along with their 5-line control bar. I was very excited about these as I am so very, very pleased with the performance of Born-Kite NS3s. I am principally a buggy rider residing in the mountains of Utah so all of my riding to date has been on various grass or artificial surface athletic fields.

    First things first, the LSs are beautiful and well constructed. They make me think of Batman which I think makes them look really cool. The 5-line control bar is a little crude IMHO, particularly in the chicken loop and donkey stick. Born kites most definitely seem better thought out and executed than Born bars.

    Flying the LS kites with the 5-line bar is sort of strange. The kites seem to require near constant nursing to maintain decent flying characteristics. The way the bar is set up you strap the chicken loop into your harness, but 50% of the load remains on the bar and thus your arms. This is because the power lines and fifth center line go around a pulley system attached to the bar and go back out again to attach to a cleat above the bar. So... when you push the bar out part way you effectively let off on the brake lines a bit and I suppose change the kites presentation angle to the wind due to a pulley system up by the kite bridles; push it out more and you further engage the fifth line and scrunch up the kites leading edge, creating an inefficient kite that dumps power. I think the LS has a nicer DP center line system than the NS3s.

    Beyond the fact that this pushing and pulling of the control bar while taking load on both the harness and your arms is unique, I've got to say that this isn't unique in a good way, IMHO. With the bar pushed out a little bit (enough to loosen up the brake lines but not so much as to scrunch up the nose of the kite) the kite will push forward a bit. This is billed as a means of keeping the kite from stalling or flying backwards. What this means in practice is that you are nursing the kite at all times in order to keep the kite flying optimally. This can certainly be done, and I'm sure would get more intuitive and natural once some sort of muscle memory set in, but the nursing of the bar is distinctly different from flying the NS3s, and IMHO not in a good way. I've got some experience flying DP with Flysurfer Peak-2s but their bar action makes sense to me and doesn't require the sort of constant attention that the LSs seem to require.

    At least in my hands the LS does not seem to behave well at the edges of the wind window even with my best attempts at good bar control. With a NS3 I can bring the kite to the extreme edge of the window and sort of park it, then nose it down or up to send it smoothly back in the other direction. With the LS if I keep it flying into the edge of the wind window it will stall and then fly backwards despite attempting to arrest this with finessing the bar. Even if I manage to time it right with bar control and stop the backward flying before it happens I didn't find that I could then reasonably get the kite to respond to turning requests and everything just sort of craps out and the kite goes to the ground if I wasn't very careful. Similarly, bringing the kite up to its Zenith and trying to park it pretty much results in the same behavior, but this time sending the kite vertically downward in a reverse flight. Here, I did usually find it possible to arrest the downward path with bar finessing, but again this is the constant nursing issue. More practice (and a better pilot!) would probably take care of some of this.

    Finally, as a buggy engine it does seem to require using two hands on the bar pretty much at all times to coax the bar in and out while steering the kite up and down (sinng for example). Not many tries under my belt, but to date I've not been able to reasonably park an LS while rolling, something that is the hallmark of the charm of the STARS. One of the beautiful things about the STARS is their ability to "park" the kite while buggying and fly it with one hand (or no hands, just nudging the bar now and again with a finger to make micro flight corrections). This is NOT happening with the LS. Yes, I know folks that buggy with kites on handles always need to use both hands, but one of the sweet things about buggying with STARS is not having to do that.

    One thing I've not had much of yet is great high wind pushing the kites upward toward their upper limits. I will say that the LSs behaved better when the wind was stronger. Of course that meant that the load on my arms was proportionally higher too....

    So.... I'm not too keen on the 5-line bar. In an attempt to get good use out of the kites themselves I tried flying them using my 3-line bar set up I use for my NS3s. Doing this is quite simple as each side's bridle systems are joined with pigtails and the pulley system is part of the 5-line bar setup, so setting these up like a NS3 is as simple as with the STARS. I shot a video of me doing as close to a head-to-head comparison as I could muster, flying the 3.0m LS static on my 3-line bar back to back with my 3.2m NS3. You will see the peculiar flying characteristics I described above. Note please that these behaviors are somewhat exaggerated with the fixed bridle set up, but the kite acts this way with the 5-line set up too. I'd say the pull of these two kites was comparable, both being impressive for their size.

    I'm not taking any real pleasure writing this up. I believe strongly in "keeping it real" on a forum like this so I'm doing it. Its hard for me because I have gotten to know Steffen over the past year and really like him and really admire that he started this business up from scratch. That coupled with my absolute LOVE of his NS3s. I'm sure he will continue to innovate with the LongStar concept and maybe even the fabled UltraStar. I keenly look forward to those innovations.

    I'd be highly interested in hearing from any other early adopters out there that also have some flying time with the LongStars.

     


    Edited by windstruck


      Report Review


    User Feedback


    windstruck

    Posted

    LongStar Second Look!


    Well STAR fans, the wind picked up considerably this afternoon and I got all three LongStars up in the air for some lively buggy riding on an artificial surface athletic field near my house. Winds were classically variable, being dead still one minute, only to be gusting 20+ the next. I'd say baseline wind when it was blowing was 10-12 mph.

    I used my custom 3-line NS3 bar with the kites only attached via their upper power bridle lines. The LongStars have a Z-Bridle setup and this time I did not tie in the free dangling lower Z line. Maybe a combination of the stronger wind and these lower lines being free, but the kites flew much better today than during my low wind static session that was the subject of my first video.

    Bottom line, the LongStars were much improved, but still not up to the smoothness of the NS3s. I could sort of "Park" the LongStars, but not like I can easily do with the NS3. Most of the time that I'd stop moving the kite and try to park it in the front of the window I felt like I was inches away from a back stall. Sort of an uneasy feeling, as if I was about to loose control of the kite. My runs were sort of short due to the surface I was on so maybe parking would have gone better with longer straight shots with cleaner wind.

    Due largely to pilot error all three kites had their little temper tantrums. You can see one for the 7m at around 0.45, one for the 3m at around 3:30, and one for the 5m in the blooper real behind the credits at around 11:45. I'm sort of proud of my save with the 3m LS. The crowd seemed to like it too because they cheered right after I saved it!  
    :angel:

     

     

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites
    windstruck

    Posted

    Following the lead of @jhn.holgate I mocked up a 5-line bar for my quiver of LongStars to allow the force to come completely through the chicken loop.  Turns out this makes the LongStars very pleasant to fly.  I have been less than thrilled with the stock 5-line LongStar bar that splits the load between the bar and chicken loop.  Too much fiddling in the air for my taste, particularly when buggying.

    I mocked up this bar as much to salvage the purchase of my LongStars as anything.  Set up as shown in the photo below (and featured in Johns LongStar 2 video - https://youtu.be/GwwvIQyTkU0 ) the LongStars fly very nicely!  Not shown in the photo (but mentioned in John's video) is making the bar's brake line pigtails about four inches longer than the main power line pigtails.  The kites themselves have Z-bridling and this extra pigtail length gets the balance of tension just right when flying.  A little adjustment will likely be needed to get the length of the central 5th line just right.  Just a touch of slack beyond tension on the 5th line seems to work well.

    With these modifications I now really like the flying characteristics of the LongStars.  I pilfered the parts I needed from the stock 5-line bar because frankly I never wanted to fly these kites again from that bar.  Set up and pack up still is nicer with the NASA Stars due to them only having three lines as compared to five, but in the air the LongStars really shine off of this bar set up.  It is particularly nice to have the brake strap for landings.

    If you own the LongStars and are also frustrated with the bar set up I strongly recommend this modification!

    LongStar Bar Mod 001.JPG

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites
    jhn.holgate

    Posted

    Good one Steve.  I'm hoping to have my long stars back for Kingston and give them a good run there and then will be able to add some more to the discussion.  

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites


    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now



×